Rejected Applicant Takes Chula Vista to Court
Laura Wilkinson Sinton, a small business owner from Coronado, applied to open a cannabis shop in Chula Vista through her company, CV Amalgamated LLC. The city rejected her application, and after learning how her paperwork was processed, she sued, accusing officials of failing to follow their own rules when scoring her bid for one of a limited number of licenses.
Chula Vista’s ordinance caps cannabis licenses at eight, with two allowed in each of the city’s four council districts. The ordinance requires background checks on every applicant and objective, merit-based assessments of each would-be licensee.
In 2022, after state appellate judges reversed a trial court ruling dismissing the initial lawsuit, the city agreed to reassess the CV Amalgamated application. The rescoring left Sinton as the top-rated applicant in one council district and second-highest in another.
Despite that result, Chula Vista again rejected the CV Amalgamated request to be licensed as a dispensary operator. The city allows two licenses per district.
The case is now awaiting a hearing by the 4th District Court of Appeal. The dispute is racking up major attorney fees on both sides.
Accusations of Arbitrary and Secret Licensing
Sinton’s attorney, David S. Demian, says the city violated its own licensing rules and failed to comply with the 4th District Court of Appeal decision handed down more than four years ago.
“The city adopted laws requiring a competitive process for cannabis licenses and then arbitrarily broke those laws,” said David S. Demian, the attorney representing Sinton. “Instead, the city engaged in costly litigation while secretly issuing licenses to the handpicked applicants of its choosing.”
“We look forward to presenting these facts to the Court of Appeal,” Demian said.
Chula Vista officials declined to comment on the escalating legal fight. They and their lawyers also refused to disclose how much the dispute is costing taxpayers, or why some cannabis licenses were approved while others, like Sinton’s, were thwarted.
In court papers, the city says it fully complied with the 2022 appellate court ruling. It says CV Amalgamated is wrongly trying to displace existing licensees and force the city to issue more permits than allowed by the ordinance.
Million Dollar Claim and Unclear Legal Costs
In addition to the initial 2020 legal complaint awaiting its appeals court hearing, CV Amalgamated has filed a separate lawsuit that could cost Chula Vista millions of dollars.
“As a direct and proximate result of the defendants’ conduct, plaintiff has been damaged in a sum not yet fully ascertained and according to proof at trial, but estimated to be not less than $13,842,281.81,” the second legal complaint states.
Months before the appeals court reversed the trial court decision, the city offered Sinton $25,000 to settle the case. A deputy city attorney wrote in 2021 that the “city feels it is in a strong position to prevail in the litigation matters.”
It is not clear whether the CV Amalgamated litigation is being funded by Chula Vista taxpayers. Officials would not say who is paying the legal costs.

